Meaning
An uncertainty or inconsistency that appears directly on the surface of a written document arises from the language used by the drafters. This condition of facial ambiguity occurs when the words themselves are capable of more than one reasonable interpretation or are contradictory. It differs from latent ambiguity, which only becomes apparent when the terms are applied to external facts.
The boundary of this concept is the text itself, meaning that no external context is needed to see that the wording is unclear.
Textual Interpretation
When a document contains contradictory terms, the meaning must be resolved by examining the document as a whole. In cases of facial ambiguity, a contract might state in one clause that a founder is entitled to twenty percent of the shares and in another clause that they have ten percent. This internal conflict creates an immediate problem that must be resolved to determine the true agreement.
It often arises when templates are poorly edited or combined without a thorough review.
Evidentiary Opening
The presence of a clear contradiction on the face of a document allows a tribunal to consider outside records to clarify the meaning. While the parol evidence rule normally prevents the use of external emails or draft documents, facial ambiguity creates an exception that lets these materials be examined. This is done to discover what the parties actually intended when they wrote the conflicting terms.
This process can require considerable time and effort from both parties to reconstruct their negotiations.
Contractual Risk
Unclear phrasing in a signed agreement introduces a risk to the stability of a startup. It allows either party to argue for an interpretation that benefits them, leading to prolonged disputes that drain the attention of the management team.