Meaning
The discovery phase of litigation includes a process where witnesses review documents to stimulate their memory. This process of refreshing recollection is common during depositions or hearings where a founder is asked about events that took place several years earlier. The document facilitates a more accurate testimony without necessarily being admitted as evidence.
Memory Assistance
Providing a prompt to a witness helps to bridge the gap between their current state of mind and the historical facts. When refreshing recollection occurs, the witness must first state that they cannot recall the information and that seeing the document would help. This ensures the testimony originates from the witness’s memory while the document serves only as a prompt.
A founder might use an email and a calendar entry to help them describe the specific terms of a meeting that would otherwise be lost to time.
Procedural Guardrail
Opposing counsel has the right to see any material used to prompt a witness and can use it during their own questioning. This rule for refreshing recollection prevents the use of biased or misleading documents to manufacture a false memory. It also allows the examiner to see if the witness is actually recalling the event or just reciting what is on the page.
The transparency of this process is the main defense against the manipulation of a witness’s account of the past.
Evidentiary Distinction
A clear line exists between using a document to help someone recall and introducing that document as a record of a past event. Refreshing recollection is about the witness’s memory, while other procedures focus on the reliability of the document itself.